Are You Paying Too Much at the Pharmacy Counter?

How to Save Money on Prescriptions

In a recent newsletter, I shared a quick example that got a lot of reactions. A member's progesterone was going to cost $35 at the pharmacy with a GoodRx coupon. Here in our office? $22.50.

That's not a typo, and it's not a special sale! That's just what happens when a medication doesn't pass through a whole line of middlemen before it gets to you.

Most people have no idea this is even possible. And with open enrollment underway, everyone is staring at premiums, deductibles, and copays right now, wondering why healthcare costs so much. So let's talk about one of the sneakiest places people overpay: the pharmacy counter.

The Short Answer

  • Are you overpaying? Maybe! For many common generics, insurance copays can be higher than the actual cash price of the medication.

  • How to check: Ask the pharmacist for the cash price, compare it to a discount card like GoodRx, and compare both to your copay.

  • At True Insight: Members can get 100+ common generic medications right here in the office at near-wholesale prices. If I don't stock yours, I can usually order it.

  • Open enrollment tip: Look at your plan's pharmacy deductible, generic copay, and lab coverage, not just the monthly premium.

 

Why Would My Copay Cost More Than the Medicine?

It sounds backwards, right? You pay for insurance so your medicine costs less. But for a lot of common, inexpensive generics, it doesn't always work that way.

Here's the simple version. Your copay is set by your plan, not by what the pill actually costs. If your plan says generics are $20, you pay $20, even if the medication itself costs a few dollars. And if you haven't met your deductible yet, you may be paying the plan's full negotiated price, which can be a lot more than the cash price.

This isn't rare! Researchers at the University of Southern California found that insurance copays were higher than the cost of the drug about a quarter of the time. A 2026 analysis of more than 62 million generic prescriptions found that when someone's generic copay was over $15, buying the same drug directly for cash saved money nearly 80% of the time.

And honestly, I'm seeing it get worse, not better. More of my members are fighting higher medication copays, and some plans now have a separate deductible just for prescriptions! It's not only medications, either. I've even seen labs for a diagnosed condition get denied (more on that below). I find myself saying "Nothing surprises me anymore!" and then the very next day, I'm in shock all over again.

The "Average Wholesale Price" Problem

Here's where it gets really frustrating. A lot of drug pricing starts from a number called the Average Wholesale Price, or AWP. The name makes it sound like what pharmacies actually pay. It isn't! For generics, AWP is often set far above the real cost. One Maine state report found that for generic drugs whose prices dropped in 2023, the AWP still averaged more than 2,000% above the manufacturer's list price.

So when your "discount" is calculated off an inflated number, it can still be a huge markup. Fair warning: once you see these numbers side by side, you might need blood pressure medicine yourself!

Pharmacy vs. GoodRx vs. True Insight: How Do the Prices Compare?

Here are a few real comparisons from medications my members take every day:

Medication (30-day supply) Retail pharmacy, cash With GoodRx True Insight member price
Progesterone 100mg (hormone) $134.45 $37.29 $22.50
Losartan 25mg (blood pressure) $127.56 $14.53 $7.20
Atorvastatin 40mg (cholesterol) $48.65 $17.32 $4.50
Levothyroxine 50mcg (thyroid) $50.56 $10.00 $3.60

Retail cash prices are the lower average retail prices listed on GoodRx. All prices checked November 2, 2026 for Raleigh-area pharmacies. Prices change often, so ask us for today's number!

Look at that losartan. $127.56 at retail, $7.20 here. Again, not a typo! And notice the progesterone GoodRx price has already crept up from $35 to $37.29 since that newsletter. Prices move around constantly, which is exactly why it pays to check.

Discount cards like GoodRx are genuinely helpful, and if one is the cheapest option for you, use it! But they're still working from retail pharmacy pricing. When I buy directly from a wholesale supplier, there are fewer hands in the pot, and my members get near-wholesale prices. The small difference covers things like the bottles (which are surprisingly pricey!) and medications that expire on my shelf when someone switches or stops a prescription.

A Real Story: Same Heart Medication, Less Than Half the Price

One of my members was paying $120 for a three-month supply of a heart medication. Not a fancy brand-name drug. A generic!

I'm always hunting for better pricing, so we went to work. First, we got it about 30% cheaper. That's a nice win, but I kept looking. Then I found it through a different supplier for more than 50% less than she'd been paying. Same medication, same dose, and now she pays under $60 for that same three-month supply.

That's more than $240 back in her pocket every year, for one prescription. Now imagine you take three or four.

How Does Getting Medications In-Office Work?

Right now, I keep about 130 medications on hand. Take out the different doses and that's still more than 100 different medications, covering a lot of what people take long-term, like blood pressure, cholesterol, thyroid, and hormone medications.

What if I don't stock yours? This is my favorite part! When a new member joins and I don't carry their medication, we look up the price together, right there in the room. We compare it to what they're paying now. Yes, even against their copay! If my price wins, I add it to my order that very moment.

You pick it up here, not in a drive-thru line. And if you have a question about it, you message me directly, not a call center. You can pay with your HSA or FSA card, too, and every invoice is itemized so you have a copy for your records if the IRS ever asks.

Same goes for labs. I don't make a profit on labs. They're how we figure out what's going on and make sure your treatment is safe, and nobody should be priced out of that. To me, marking up necessary labs is unethical. This isn't Botox for wrinkles or a Brazilian butt lift (LOL). This is your heart, your brain, and your ability to live a long life without suffering or debility!

What Can't I Get Through the Office?

I want to be upfront so there are no surprises:

  • Controlled substances: I don't stock them. I'm not a freestanding pharmacy, and the security and liability requirements don't make sense for our practice right now. Those prescriptions still go to your regular pharmacy. No worries, though, we'll work together to get you the best price!

  • Brand-name medications: I don't usually stock these (other than samples when they're available), because most of my members do great on generics. But if you need a brand because of side effects or how you tolerate the generic, I can order it for you.

  • Everything else: If it's not a controlled medication, just ask! We'll price it together, and if mine is better (I'm pretty sure it will be!), it goes on my order right then.

What Should I Look at During Open Enrollment?

Open enrollment for 2027 Marketplace plans runs November 1, 2026 through January 15, 2027 on HealthCare.gov, which is what North Carolina uses. Pick a plan by December 15 if you want coverage to start January 1. Medicare's annual enrollment runs October 15 through December 7. Insurers asked for a median 15% premium increase for 2027, so a lot of people will be shopping around this year.

I understand feeling the pressure of this time crunch. But it's worth taking a couple of hours to look at your family's real needs and how a plan would actually benefit you. When you compare plans, look past the monthly premium:

Is there a separate pharmacy deductible?

  • What is your generic copay or coinsurance, really? If it's over $15, cash is often cheaper.

  • Which tier are your medications on? Drug lists change every year.

  • Paying cash or using a discount card may not count toward your deductible. If you rarely meet your deductible anyway, that may not matter much. If you have big medical costs coming up, it might.

  • What labs are covered? Some plans now only pay for an annual "preventive" screening panel. I recently had a patient whose insurance rejected labs for her diagnosed thyroid condition. She could have paid $12 through our office. Instead, she got a surprise bill from a big corporate lab for almost $115!

For some people, an indemnity plan, a health share, or other catastrophic coverage may be a much better fit, especially paired with a truly comprehensive DPC practice like ours. Just read the fine print: health shares aren't insurance, and not every option lets you use an HSA.

Here's what "comprehensive" looks like in real life. Recently, I kept a gentleman out of the ER by drawing his labs, getting them processed stat, giving IV fluids, and following up closely until he was better. Otherwise, he likely would have ended up in the hospital at least overnight. And interestingly, a short stay like that often gets classified as "observation" instead of an admission, which Medicare and other plans can bill very differently!

And this ties right back to my HSA post! Starting in 2026, bronze and catastrophic Marketplace plans count as HSA-compatible, and qualifying direct primary care memberships ($150 a month or less for individuals, $300 for families) can be paid with HSA dollars. Prescription medications are an HSA-eligible expense too. That's why more people are pairing a lower-premium plan and an HSA with a DPC membership for everyday care, and keeping insurance for the big stuff. A benefits advisor can help you figure out if that fits your situation.

Nobody Should Overpay for Healthcare

Here's how I see it. I don't care if you're living paycheck to paycheck or traveling the world on a billion-dollar salary. We shouldn't be overpaying for things, and definitely not for healthcare. The greed in healthcare infuriates me!

Gucci shoes? Sure. Convenience store chips? Sure. Grandma's blood pressure medicine? Go pound salt! (No pun intended, because salt raises blood pressure!)

So before you pay at the pharmacy counter, talk to me. Let's see what we can do.

Already a member? Send me your medication list through SigmaMD and I'll run the numbers with you.

Not a member yet? Schedule a Meet & Greet and bring your medication list. We'll compare prices together.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is GoodRx cheaper than using insurance?

Sometimes. For many common generics, a discount card price can be lower than your copay, especially if you haven't met your deductible. It's always worth comparing before you pay. Members also get a prescription discount code through the SigmaMD app! Not long ago, a member needed a medication my supplier couldn't get, and the SigmaMD discount code saved her more than GoodRx did.

Can a pharmacist tell me the cash price?

Yes! Federal laws passed in 2018 banned pharmacy "gag clauses," so pharmacists are allowed to tell you when paying cash would cost less than using your insurance. Just ask.

Does paying cash for a prescription count toward my deductible?

Often it doesn't, because the purchase doesn't go through your insurance. But some plans let you submit your receipts so it counts, so it's worth asking yours.

Can True Insight members get medications in the office?

Yes. Members can get more than 100 common generic medications in the office at near-wholesale prices, and Dr. Barrett can order just about any other non-controlled medication. Controlled substances are not stocked.

Can I use my HSA for direct primary care and medications?

Starting in 2026, qualifying direct primary care memberships of $150 a month or less ($300 for families) can be paid with HSA funds, and prescription medications are an HSA-eligible expense. True Insight members can pay for in-office medications with an HSA or FSA card and get an itemized invoice. Check your own plan details or ask a benefits advisor.

Stay well out there,

Dr. B

Next
Next

It’s That Time of Year!!